My eighth-grade history teacher once told us a story when we were on one of our many random topics in his class. He said that he had once debated the issue of making stuff "look like America" with a college professor once, and his college professor told him this (it's paraphrased): the guy was going to have heart surgery in a couple of months, and he, quite frankly, didn't want a team of surgeons that looked like America, he wanted the best team of surgeons he could get. We can apply these same lessons to the Supreme Court: Do we want the best set of nine judges in the country (or, at the very least, do we want to have that ideal in our selections), or do we want a group of people who "look like America."
Guess what? Clarence Thomas was picked because he made the Court look like America. Do I dislike the views of Clarence Thomas, and/or do I disagree with his style? Not really. I disagree with why the first Bush picked him.
And guess what--if we're going to make the court "look like America", why don't we make EVERYTHING, and I mean EVERYTHING, look like America. Is this going to be a series of straw-men? Perhaps. Am I fond tonight of asking rhetorical questions? Apparently.
Black people make up perhaps 12% of America; they have thus no complaint about being underrepresented on the Court, because 1/9 is 11%, and 11 is a lot closer to 12 than 22 (and do we really want halves of people, given some of the half-wits on the Court now (cough, Kennedy, cough)).
So...should we develop another Court-packing plan, and make sure the Court "looks like America?" Or should we all place more emphasis on looking like we have a brain and devote ourselves to getting rid of the nonsense that absolutely everything has to be a microcosm of American society? What's next, should we put MBAs and chemistry PhDs on the court, because it would "look like America?"
There are a few political concepts that really, truly annoy me, and all the stuff I write about tends to come down to these three things.
1)Everything has to "look like America."
2)Every culture is equally good and valid AND the hand-in-hand idea that there is no such thing as a fact or objective truth.
3)Black people (or pick your minority) deserve special treatment b/c past wrongs.